So You Want to Manage Stress Without Using Food
BLACK IRON RADIO EP. 394: So You Want to Manage Stress Without Using Food
Stress eating is normal, and when the snack is gone, the stress is still there.
Ryann, Joyce, and Nic talk about managing stress without leaning on food. They start with the difference between good stress and the kind that wears you down, then get into why your brain heads for the pantry when things are rough. They also share what they actually use with clients: a dopamine menu, a go-to meal that’s always ready, and what to do after you stress eat.
Plus: why one stressful eating moment doesn’t cancel the rest of your day.
It’s a high-stress day, and you end up in the pantry or the drive-thru, trying to take the edge off. You feel better for a minute, and then the stress is still there. In this episode of Black Iron Radio, Ryann, Joyce, and Nic talk through why that happens and what to do instead.
Not All Stress Is Bad
There are two kinds of stress. Eustress is the good kind: a new job, a roller coaster, a first date, a hard workout. Your body responds to it and adapts, which is how fitness and growth happen. Distress is the kind that feels like danger, like grief, money trouble, an injury, or a deadline you’re about to miss.
If we treat all stress as bad, we don’t get very far. We need some of it to grow. The goal is regulating stress, not getting rid of it, and that doesn’t mean living at a high-stress pace all the time.
Why Your Brain Heads for Food
When we’re stressed, our body activates one of its main stress systems, and cortisol is part of that. Cortisol isn’t bad, and we need it for things like blood sugar, energy, and sleep. When stress is chronic, though, it can influence appetite and cravings.
Nobody wants a bowl of broccoli at that point. Foods rich in sugar, fat, or both activate your brain’s reward system, including dopamine. So you get stressed, you eat something delicious, you feel relief, and your brain learns that it worked. Repeat it enough and it becomes a loop that happens on its own.
Sometimes you’re not chasing the food itself. You’re chasing the break from stress the food gave you.
Sometimes It’s Just Hunger
Stress doesn’t hit everyone the same way. Some people barely eat on a stressful day, then get home and are ravenous. That gets labeled emotional eating, but part of it is that they weren’t fueled all day. If you’ve ever blamed yourself for a night in the pantry, check your whole day first.
None of our coaches have this figured out perfectly either. Cheez-Its, M&M’s, and Goldfish have all had their moments.
Catch It Early
Most people don’t say they’re stressed until burnout has already started. Schedule changes, back to school, a new role, money changes, weddings, and new babies all trigger a stress response. Pay attention when things that used to feel easy start feeling harder, or you notice you’re more irritable than usual.
Build a Dopamine Menu
This one comes from Joyce. Make a list of things that bring you comfort or pleasure outside of food, and break it up like a menu. Appetizers are what you can do in two minutes: stand outside, take a deep breath, sip water, dim the lights. Entrées are for when you have 20 or 30 minutes. Three or four items in each section is plenty.
Keep it somewhere you’ll see it, like your phone or the fridge. When you’re stressed, you forget everything you’ve learned, and the list is what interrupts the loop.
Other Things That Help
Let go of the hustle. There’s a lot of glorification of the grind online. It’s okay to manage your stress, and it’s good to. If you never rest, you’ll burn out fast.
Talk to someone. Telling someone you’re stressed can feel like a failure when everyone is hustling. Having a person who notices you’re off before you do is helpful. Therapy can be a good option too, when it’s accessible to you.
Move, but watch the intensity. If exercise is your only stress relief, add something else. A walk with the dog or an easy jog works. If your nervous system is already fried from your day, an all-out interval session can add to it.
Set boundaries. Ryann shared that the podcast she was supposed to record earlier in the year got scrapped because she and two other coaches were too stressed to do it justice.
Keep self-talk neutral. If positive self-talk isn’t happening, aim for neutral. Negative self-talk adds to the stress, and “why me” thinking keeps you from noticing the small good moments.
Plan Your Food Ahead of Time
If you know a stressful week is coming, plan for it when you’re not stressed. Keep a go-to balanced meal that’s quick, like a restaurant order or chicken, microwave rice, and frozen veggies, so you have an easy choice at 8:30 at night when you realize you haven’t eaten.
Enjoyment matters too. If you’re eating meals you don’t enjoy, you’re more likely to look for something highly palatable anyway. You can have a meal that fills you up and a food you love in the same week.
Slow Down and Let Yourself Enjoy It
Our coaches don’t think any food is good or bad. If you have a craving, eat it, and do it with some attention. Plate it, sit down, take a few sips of water first, and notice what you actually need in that moment. Ryann eats a treat every day, and Joyce and Nic do something similar.
Another habit Ryann gives clients is one meal with no screens, at least four times a week. Clients hate it at first and find it awkward. Once they do it more, they tend to enjoy it, because it’s sometimes the only quiet time they get all day.
She also asks clients to break a food rule every week. One client eats pie for breakfast once a week. It isn’t the most nutritious breakfast every day, but it helps her let go of the idea that pie is bad.
After You Stress Eat
Treat it as a data point. Instead of “I ate the whole bag of Cheez-Its and I’m bad,” ask what was going on beforehand. Were you tired, lonely, overstimulated, or hadn’t eaten? A client of Nic’s felt great after one drink and ended up having four. Looking at what was happening between drinks one and two is more useful than beating yourself up.
Joyce tells clients to think of the day as four quarters of a basketball game. A stressful eating moment in one quarter doesn’t erase the others. Your body responds to the average of what you do over months and years, so one moment doesn’t change where you’re headed.
Give the need some attention when you can: connection if you were lonely, rest if you were exhausted, quiet if you were overstimulated, or an actual meal. The more you ignore the need, the stronger the urge gets.
You Don’t Have to Handle It Alone
Some people avoid working with a coach because they’re ashamed of their behaviors and expect us to judge them. Nobody here is going to tell you you’re bad for eating pie. Joyce likes to say coaches are only a few chapters ahead of you. If you’re in a stressful season, that’s a great time to ask for support.
The Takeaway
Stress eating is normal, and relying on it isn’t something that works for long. Make a list of things you can do instead, plan ahead for busy weeks, and get ahead of stress before burnout does. You don’t have to handle it all on your own.
🎙️ WANT MORE? SUBSCRIBE TO BLACK IRON RADIO!
If you enjoyed this conversation, check out more episodes of Black Iron Radio, where we cut through the noise and give you real, no-BS advice on feeling, performing, and looking your best. Each week we share practical nutrition, training, and wellness strategies and tips to help you succeed.
